Some thoughts on writing and editing

Writing can be an overwhelming experience, especially for those with attentional deficit issues. Here are some tricks I have learned to help reduce my cognitive overload when writing and editing:

 

Express yourself first, edit later

  • Don’t expect the first expression of an idea to be elegant, well-formed, or to make any sense
  • Through skillful editing, silk purses can be made from sow’s ears
  • The writing/editing process is highly iterative; don’t be surprised if it takes time

Writing as a tool for thinking

  • As you write you might start to think about things in a new way
  • It may be difficult to predict where a document might lead before you actually write it
  • This emergent aspect is what makes writing exciting

Mechanical editing

  • A large part of editing is mechanical or technical and thus could, in theory, be automated (that is, any monkey could be trained to do it)
  • Such editing need not be too difficult conceptually

Good content requires more than technique

  • Even with perfect technical editing, there is no guarantee that the content of writing will have any value

Number of words

  • If you can express the same thought in fewer words, then use fewer words
  • However, don’t be too miserly with words; excessive density or compactness of writing should be avoided

Contiguity of similar ideas

  • Put ideas that are similar, next to one another, using cut and paste
  • If there is repetition, then get rid of something
  • Don’t say the same thing in different parts of the same document, except occasionally for rhetorical effect

Order and flow

  • Often, sufficient ideas are present in a document but are not in the proper order
  • Put ideas in the proper order so that they flow well and unfold elegantly

Conclusions

  • If you make a conclusion using words such as ‘therefore’ or ‘so’, you should support your conclusion with a progression of plausible assertions
  • Don’t assume, as a given, what you are tying to prove
  • Sometimes lines of reasoning lead to crazy conclusions; sometimes such conclusions turn out to be true

Avoid conclusions if necessary

  • Often the available evidence is too sketchy or ambiguous to make firm conclusions
  • Asking the right questions might be a worthwhile contribution

Back to front structure

  • If you come to an interesting conclusion at the end of a document, it might be a good idea to put that idea at the beginning so people have some idea where you are headed

Hidden assumptions

  • Hidden assumptions are things assumed to be true without their existence being acknowledged and with no evidence of their truthfulness provided
  • Try to identity and examine hidden assumptions; this can often be an interesting and fruitful enquiry

Knowledge as ‘frozen ignorance’

  • Often things that ‘everyone knows’ turn out not to be true
  • Assume that your ignorance of the world is much greater than your knowledge
This entry was posted in Writing. Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>